23 Vegetables That Just Aren’t Worth It – Here’s What to Grow Instead

Plant Care
By Aria Moore

Gardening enthusiasts often face the dilemma of choosing the right crops to plant. Some vegetables, despite their popularity, demand more than they give back.

In this article, we explore 23 vegetables that might not be worth the effort and suggest better alternatives to cultivate.

1. Celery

© Gardener’s Path

Celery might seem like a staple, but its finicky nature makes it a challenge. With a need for constant watering and rich soil, celery often yields disappointment. Instead, consider growing Swiss chard.

Swiss chard offers vibrant color and a similar crunch without the fuss. It’s more forgiving of less-than-ideal conditions and provides a continuous harvest. Plus, its nutritional profile rivals that of celery, making it a smarter choice for your garden.

2. Cauliflower

© Reuse Grow Enjoy

Cauliflower, though delicious, is a demanding guest in the garden. Prone to pests and requiring precise growing conditions, it may not reward your efforts. Consider broccoli as a substitute.

Broccoli shares a similar taste with fewer challenges. It’s resilient, easier to grow, and still packs a nutritional punch. Plus, its vibrant green hue adds beauty to any garden while offering a more reliable yield.

3. Asparagus

© The Topeka Capital-Journal

Asparagus takes patience, with a harvest waiting period of three years. This investment of time and space may not appeal to every gardener. Opt for rhubarb instead.

Rhubarb plants grow robustly and lend a tart, unique flavor to dishes. They thrive with less attention and reward you season after season. With its vibrant red stalks, rhubarb is both ornamental and practical for culinary use.

4. Artichokes

© Savor the Southwest

Artichokes are finicky, needing precise soil and climate to thrive. This makes them less compatible with many home gardens. For a simpler choice, try growing cardoons.

Cardoons are cousins of the artichoke, boasting similar flavors but are more adaptable to varying conditions. They don’t demand as much care, making them a more rewarding and practical choice for your plot.

5. Eggplant

© A Nourishing Plate

Eggplants require warm temperatures and are susceptible to a variety of pests. These demands can frustrate gardeners hoping for a bountiful yield. Consider growing zucchini instead.

Zucchini grows prolifically, even in less-than-ideal conditions, offering a continuous harvest. Its versatility in the kitchen makes it a favorite among home cooks, and it requires far less maintenance than eggplant.

6. Brussels Sprouts

© From Garden to Soup Bowl

Brussels sprouts need a long growing season and are prone to pests, making them a tough choice for home gardens. Swap them out for kale.

Kale is hardy, grows quickly, and provides multiple harvests. Its nutritional benefits are well-known, and it can withstand a variety of conditions. Plus, its lush leaves add beauty to any garden setting, making it a worthwhile replacement.

7. Lettuce

© Reddit

Lettuce can be challenging to grow due to its preference for cool weather and susceptibility to bolting. Instead, try spinach.

Spinach is more heat-tolerant and offers continual harvests. It thrives in various climates and is packed with nutrients, making it a satisfying, low-maintenance substitute. This leafy green is as versatile in the kitchen as it is easy to grow in the garden.

8. Carrots

© Gardening Know How

Carrots require loose, sandy soil to develop properly. They often disappoint with misshapen roots in compacted soils. Turn to radishes for a better experience.

Radishes thrive in a variety of soil types and mature rapidly, offering quick satisfaction. Their peppery crunch adds zest to dishes, and they’re less demanding than carrots, making them a gardener’s delight.

9. Onions

© The Spruce

Onions need long growing seasons and are sensitive to soil conditions, often leading to underwhelming results. Opt for green onions instead.

Green onions mature faster and are more forgiving of soil variances. They add a fresh, mild flavor to dishes and require less space. Their adaptability and ease of growth make them an excellent alternative to traditional onions.

10. Corn

© Modern Farmer

Corn demands ample space, rich soil, and consistent watering, which can be burdensome for home gardeners. Try growing beans instead.

Beans enrich the soil through nitrogen fixation and require less care while delivering high yields. They’re versatile in the kitchen and can thrive even in smaller garden spaces, making them a more practical and rewarding choice.

11. Watercress

© Better Homes & Gardens

Watercress needs constant moisture and a specific pH balance, demanding for most gardeners. Consider arugula as a replacement.

Arugula grows with ease, even in less-than-ideal conditions, and brings a peppery punch to the table. Its rapid growth and minimal water requirements make it a smart alternative, ensuring a flavorful and hassle-free harvest.

12. Peas

© Botanical Interests

Peas prefer cool, moist environments, making them less suited for warm climates. Try growing bush beans instead.

Bush beans thrive in warmth and offer extended harvests. They require less support and are resistant to many common pests, providing a more reliable and bountiful crop, perfect for gardeners seeking ease and productivity.

13. Cabbage

© College of Health and Human Sciences – Colorado State University

Cabbage is a magnet for pests and demands specific growing conditions, presenting challenges to gardeners. Swap it with collard greens.

Collard greens are hardy, pest-resistant, and easy to grow. They deliver a similar taste and nutritional value with less trouble. Their robustness and adaptability make them ideal for a hassle-free gardening experience.

14. Beets

© Sow Right Seeds

Beets require specific soil conditions and can be fussy about watering. Opt for turnips instead.

Turnips are easier to grow and adapt well to different soils. They mature quickly and offer both edible roots and greens. Their versatility and lower maintenance needs make them a more appealing choice for gardeners seeking reliability and flavor.

15. Radicchio

© Gardening Know How

Radicchio demands precise conditions, often bolting in the heat. Consider growing endive instead.

Endive shares a similar bitterness but is more tolerant of varying climates. It grows robustly and provides a unique flavor profile, making it a smart and satisfying choice for those seeking a reliable leafy green with less hassle.

16. Fennel

© Reddit

Fennel requires well-drained soil and specific conditions, making it tricky to cultivate. Try dill as a substitute.

Dill shares fennel’s anise-like flavor but grows with ease in various soils and climates. It offers culinary diversity and requires minimal care, all while attracting beneficial insects to the garden, enhancing both its utility and appeal.

17. Turnips

© Sow Right Seeds

Turnips, though sturdy, can attract pests and require specific care. Opt for parsnips instead.

Parsnips are hardy and less prone to pest issues. They offer a sweet, nutty flavor that complements a variety of dishes, and their resilience makes them easier for gardeners to grow successfully. Parsnips provide a rewarding alternative with less effort required.

18. Kohlrabi

© University of Maryland Extension

Kohlrabi requires careful soil management and is susceptible to pests. Swap it for radishes.

Radishes are quick to mature, demand less attention, and adapt well to various soil types. Their peppery flavor adds zest to meals, and their fast growth makes them a favorite for gardeners looking for a quick and easy harvest.

19. Sweet Potatoes

© Homestead and Chill

Sweet potatoes demand warm soil and extended growing periods, which can be taxing. Try growing squash instead.

Squash thrives in various conditions and requires less maintenance. Its versatility in the kitchen and prolific yields make it a valuable addition to any garden, offering both convenience and culinary delight without the extended wait.

20. Okra

© The Spruce

Okra requires ample heat and can be prickly to handle, deterring some gardeners. Opt for growing cucumbers instead.

Cucumbers flourish in warm climates and offer a refreshing crunch. They’re easier to pick and handle, providing abundant harvests with less hassle. A staple in many culinary dishes, cucumbers are both practical and rewarding to grow.

21. Pumpkins

© Gardener’s Path

Pumpkins need a lot of space and a lengthy growing season, which can overwhelm small gardens. Try gourds instead.

Gourds offer similar aesthetic appeal and are easier to grow in confined spaces. They require less time to mature and can serve various decorative and practical purposes, making them an excellent choice for gardeners with limited room.

22. Squash

© The Spruce

Squash can fall victim to pests like squash vine borers, causing frustration for gardeners. Consider zucchini as an alternative.

Zucchini is more pest-resistant and grows prolifically, even in less-than-perfect conditions. Its versatility in the kitchen and ease of cultivation make it a popular choice, offering continuous harvests with minimal effort.

23. Cucumbers

© Harvest to Table

Cucumbers can struggle with diseases and require trellising, posing challenges to gardeners. Try growing melons instead.

Melons thrive in similar conditions but offer a sweeter reward. They require less structural support and provide a refreshing taste, perfect for those looking to diversify their garden with minimal hassle and maximal enjoyment.